Cold Leads Killing Your Insurance Sales?

Switch to our exclusive lead generation system and start seeing real ROI.

Start Getting Quality Leads in Minutes

By submitting this form, you agree to receive calls, emails, and text messages from Flying Goat Agency regarding your inquiry.

Still Dealing with Low-Quality Leads?

Some Problems You’re Probably Facing

Low quality leads, bad data
Leads are shared or recycled
No CRM, Follow up system, or Organized data
Low quality ad content
You waste time chasing dead ends
You don’t control your pipeline
No lead tracking
Low contact rates or hard to reach

Our Solution: Exclusive Leads That Are Ready to Talk

Exclusive leads — never shared or resold
Real-time delivery
Higher intent = interested
CRM + automation ready
Strategic ad targeting
Proven performance, real results
Lead replacement policy

Behind the Brand. Beyond the Ordinary.

Testimonials

"I’ve purchased leads before, but they were always shared or unresponsive. With Flying Goat Agency, it’s a completely different story. Every lead is exclusive, and they actually want to talk insurance. I closed five policies in my first two weeks. It’s the first lead system that truly works for me."

"I run a small agency, so every hour and dollar counts. With Flying Goat Agency , I was up and running fast, and the leads started coming in right away. The built-in follow-up automation saves me so much time and keeps prospects engaged without me constantly checking in."

"We were spending thousands on cold, recycled leads that never converted. It felt like we were chasing people who had no interest. Then everything changed. The lead quality is incredible these are real people actively looking for insurance. In just two months, we’ve doubled our policy count and are already planning to scale up."

"I’ve worked with several lead vendors, but none have come close to the results I’m seeing now. The leads are local, qualified, and ready to talk. Plus, the team is responsive and actually cares about helping us succeed, it feels more like a growth partner than a vendor."

"I was skeptical at first, but now I wish I had started sooner. I’m getting 5–8 qualified leads a day, and my closing rate has jumped. It’s also nice to have full transparency with a live dashboard to track every dollar. No fluff, just real results."

Choose Flying Goat Agency

Your Lead Generation Partner for Insurance Growth

50+

high-converting lead campaigns every month.

24/7

Lead generation and nurturing even while you sleep

$100k

Premiums closed by clients in just the last 6 months.

Which Model Suits You Best?

Compare our two lead generation approaches to find your perfect fit

Lead Buyer Program

Best For

Agents who want plug-and-play leads

Effort Level

Minimal – we handle everything

Ad Branding

FGA branded ads

Control & Flexibility

Fixed volume, consistent delivery

Tech & CRM Ready

Simple: Email + Google Sheet

Speed to Launch

Fast – campaigns already running

Long-Term Value

Instant pipeline boost

Custom Lead Generation

Best For

Teams, regions, and top producers looking to scale

Effort Level

Collaborative – we build it under your brand

Ad Branding

Your brand, your name, your visibility

Control & Flexibility

Scalable, adjustable campaign control

Tech & CRM Ready

Built for deep CRM integration + automated follow-up

Speed to Launch

Moderate – campaigns built to fit your brand

Long-Term Value

Stronger close rates + brand growth over time

Get Exclusive, High-Intent Leads Delivered Directly to You.

No Setup, No Ad Management, No Stress.

Exclusive Leads Never Shared

$60/Lead (Private Health)

50 Lead Minimums

You’ll never share leads with other agents. Every lead is 100% yours.

Leads are sent instantly to your email, Google Sheet, or CRM.

We run the campaigns under our brand, all you do is follow up and close.

We’ll replace any lead that’s from the wrong state or over 7 days old.

We follow all platform and carrier guidelines, no shady tactics.

Plug your leads into your follow-up system or let us help set one up (additional cost).

Switch to Quality, Exclusive Insurance Leads Today!

Happy Clients

Lead Generation Plans

Offering exclusive, high-quality leads for life, health, auto & commercial insurance.

Flexible Lead Packages

Custom Pricing Options

Lead generation plans tailored to your niche, goals, and budget pay only for what you need.

Proven Impact

Growing Your Business

Thousands of leads delivered. Hundreds of agents scaling faster.

Dedicated Support Team

Expert Help When You Need It

We handle setup, support, and everything in between.

Grow with Us & Get Rewarded

300+ Agents

Trust Us and are actively growing with our qualified lead support.

15+ New Agencies

Launch campaigns with us every month. Yours could be next.

85% Closures

Clients see high appointment rates, no cold outreach.

100% Quality. 0% Guesswork.

You’ll never share leads with other agents, each one is generated specifically for your business.

We only count leads who take action, whether it’s a form submission, call, or scheduled appointment.

All leads are tracked, scored, and optimized using real-time performance analytics to ensure your ROI keeps improving.

Custom Lead Gen Campaign

Build your branded lead machine with full creative and ad management support.

Your Brand

Full Creative

Management

Reporting

CRM Ready

Goat Basic

$5,700/mo

Ad Spend: $2,000

Ads run under your brand
Full creative production
End-to-end campaign management
Advanced tracking & reporting
CRM & automation ready
5 ad videos + 5 ad graphics

Goat Essential

$10,000/mo

Ad Spend: $5,000

Ads run under your brand
Full creative production
End-to-end campaign management
Advanced tracking & reporting
CRM & automation ready
10 ad videos + 5 ad graphics

Flying Goat

$18,000/mo

Ad Spend: $10,000

Ads run under your brand
Full creative production
End-to-end campaign management
Advanced tracking & reporting
CRM & automation ready
20 ad videos + 10 ad graphics
Priority concierge service

Custom Lead Gen Campaign (Without Ad Content)

If you prefer to provide us with your own ad content needed to succeed

Your Brand

Full Creative

Management

Reporting

CRM Ready

Goat Basic

$4,200/mo

Ad Spend: $2,000

Goat Essential

$7,500/mo

Ad Spend: $5,000

Flying Goat

$13,000/mo

Ad Spend: $10,000

Meet the G.O.A.T.s

Jason Skeldon

Spencer Beaudreault

Doug Hensel

Maliyah Perry

What Makes Us the Smart Choice for Insurance Lead Generation?

Trusted Nationwide

Thousands of insurance agents nationwide trust us to fuel their growth

Extensive Experience

10 years of helping insurance professionals grow with high-converting lead strategies

Strategic Approach

Custom lead generation campaigns built to match your goals, niche, and budget

High Satisfaction

Clients stay with us because our leads deliver real results, more appointments, more policies, more growth

3-Step Process to Start Getting Qualified Insurance Leads

Fill Out the Form

Tell us about your business, target audience, and the type of insurance leads you need.

Choose Campaign

We’ll recommend a lead strategy tailored to your goals, flexible, scalable, and within budget.

Launch & Get Leads

We handle the setup. You start receiving exclusive, ready-to-convert leads within days.

HAPPY CLIENTS

See What Success Sounds Like.

"Flying Goat Agency provided us with the tools and expertise to enhance our brand's digital footprint. Their dedicated team ensured our campaigns were successful and impactful, driving more leads than ever before."

Brightstar Chiropractic

"Partnering with Flying Goat Agency has transformed our online presence. Their argeted strategies and relentless effort have significantly increased our visibility and customer engagement. Highly recommend for anyone looking to elevate their digital marketing game!"

Health Insurance Agency

"Cannot say enough about the quality of service Spencer + Flying Goat has provided in generating meaningful leads for our business. Not only has our LinkedIn profile grown exponentially in just over a year (from 300 connections to over 4700 connections), but through Spencer's diligence, transparency, and constant communications, he has been able to help unlock connections with MLB, NFL, Adidas, and many other brands and organization that fit our ideal customers. Highly recommended."

Video Production Services

"Flying Goat is the perfect solution for any business looking to expand their brand, create a community but most importantly convert to paying customers. Lead acquisition and marketing costs is one of the biggest expenses of a business. Spencer and his team has expanded our reach and in less then a month we are getting 3 to 5 new appointments per day with my ideal clients. In less them 3 weeks we have been able to triple our initial investment and grow our business. Thank you!"

Tax Prep Services

"Spencer & Flying Goat have been a game changer for my three businesses, taking them to another level with his business development, marketing, and sales knowledge. Through Linkedin sales campaigns, networking and referral partner connections, and target marketing strategy development, he was able to drive niche- specific warm leads that led to seamless client on-boarding with systems that he helped us establish and then let them run in the background with very little effort on our our end. If you're looking to grow & scale your business, it's not about HOW you're going to do it, it is WHO will help you get there...so hiring Spencer is a no- brainer!!"

Health & Wellness

Kayla

About Us

The Flying Goat Agency Advantage

At Flying Goat Agency Options, we specialize in generating high-quality, exclusive leads for insurance professionals. From independent agents to large agencies, we help our clients scale faster with proven digital marketing strategies tailored to the insurance industry.

With campaigns running across multiple states and niches, including life, health, Medicare, and commercial insurance, we’ve built a reputation for reliability, results, and real growth.

Our mission is simple: to remove the guesswork from lead generation so you can focus on what you do best, closing deals and protecting lives. Backed by expert support and transparent performance tracking, we’re here to help you build a stronger pipeline, one qualified lead at a time.

Discover What Sets Flying Goat Agency Apart

Flying Goat Agency

100% insurance leads for predictable growth
Campaigns tailored to your goals and budget
Fast setup with hands-free automation
Dedicated support from industry experts
Proven ROI with high-converting leads and referral rewards

Other Agencies

Shared or recycled leads that don’t convert
One-size-fits-all pricing with little flexibility
Complex onboarding and unclear setup
Low ROI and few (if any) client incentives
Slow or limited support when you need help most

Flying Goat Agency

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What type of leads do you provide?

We deliver exclusive, high-intent leads for life, health, Medicare, auto, and commercial insurance.

Are the leads shared with other agents?

No. All leads are 100% exclusive and generated specifically for your business.

How soon will I start receiving leads?

Most campaigns go live within 3–5 business days after onboarding.

Do you offer pay-per-lead or monthly packages?

Yes, we offer flexible pricing, choose between pay-per-lead or custom monthly plans.

Are these leads pre-qualified?

Yes. Every lead is action-based, they’ve shown genuine interest by filling out a form or making contact.

Can you target specific states or niches?

Absolutely. We tailor campaigns to your preferred region, insurance type, and ideal client profile.

Is there support if I need help?

Yes, our dedicated support team is here to assist you throughout your campaign.